Tough case…when the gifted student doesn’t even fit within the already complex “gifted student mold.” Frustrating.
Were you thinking I meant for the teacher? Although it can be frustrating for the teacher and other students in the room, have you ever pondered how frustrated the underachiever may be?
Dr. Betty Watson. Summer of my senior year of college. Kindergarten courses. I was frustrated because a student I was tutoring could not recall any of the letters of the alphabet. I would show an “r” and then ask him what it was. Zero recollection. I went to Dr. Watson for advice.
On the board, she wrote random symbols…quickly. Covered them up and asked me to recall them. In her sweet little voice she leaned toward me, and gentle said, “Kids don’t want to be different. If they can, they will. If they don’t, figure out why.”
Do we? Are are we too focused on how we (the teacher) need the performances, answers, and behaviors to be or look?
In the article about under achieving students, this line resonated with me…
“In a number of cases, a difference in learning style has hindered the progress of a gifted child. Peterson (2001) points out that creative children have a tendency to underachieve because their thinking style diverges so drastically from the convergent style rewarded by schools.”
If I’m looking at individual children, would I notice this? Do I stop and remember that kids have real feelings that go really deep affecting every action or reaction? That maybe they don’t even realize why they are doing what they are or are not doing?
The article also addresses how when dealing with an underachiever, we must look closely at each individual. Each intervention must be carefully designed to address the particular issues trapping the child in a negative feedback loop of underachieving.
One place to begin planning an intervention is to consider the strengths of the student.
From the article…
Stay Focused on the Child’s Gifts. When examining a child’s underachievement, always begin by focusing on strengths; a deficiency approach encourages the child to focus on weaknesses even more than before. At each point the investigation needs to find the most effective ways to involve the child in the pursuit and exploration of personal talents and interests. This builds the confidence and strength the child needs to manage problem areas. A gifted underachiever once wrote Sylvia Rimm a letter that expresses perfectly the importance of focusing on the gift:
I remember you told me to continue and explore my creativity through writing and acting because that is how I would truly find my strengths. I remember how you taught me to manage my life strategically because this would help my confusing and random, inconsistent behavior. I finally remember that you told me to never be afraid to express myself no matter what others thought. (2001, p. 350)
Here’s the article.
Underachieving Article
To gain the courage to express yourself…no matter what others are thinking…that’s not easy for most of us. How do you help your students discover their strengths and courage to express themselves?
Find the students who are hiding behind “underachieving” tendencies and be their champion. Make a difference.