Caution: Read at your own risk. If you aren’t in the mood for self-reflection and direct discussion, choose another day to read this blog.
Do you ever read an article, blog, or story and ask yourself, “Who am I in the story?” (By the way, forcing students to consider the story from a different perspective is EXTREMELY higher order.)
With the history of gifted education, it’s not surprising why some seem to be quick to answer in defense (okay, defensively) to justify the needs of these students (I include high achieving with these kiddos in 95% of what I say.). It dates back to early 1900’s…or earlier. Funding swings back and forth. Opportunities swing back and forth. Acceptance of the definition of gifted or “adverse affect” swings back and forth.
Federal money (Javits Grant) provides little if any (some years $0), and its affect on gifted is indirect but important! State funding…gifted is protected in the State of TN because the State includes it under the special education umbrella, but actual $ to spend…not so much.
Sputnik changed society’s focus. No Child Left Behind changed the focus. Just when it seems something will fall in the favor of these students, another obstacle rushes in front. Our society seems to have the concept of “I know they need more, and we’ll get there. But first we need to do this…they’ll be okay because they are smart” replaying on a vicious cycle. Recently this nation wide concern seems to be getting a little more press. But will it make a difference THIS time?
To understand why this topic seems to put some on the defense, one must understand that every single inch of progress literally feels like it has been at the expense of someone’s entire career.
So, back to the original question. When you read stories, do you challenge yourself to look through the eyes of someone else? The parent. The teacher. The news reporter. The child. Do you REALLY consider the point of view and ask yourself how you contribute to the success or the stumbling block of others? Or let’s be more specific. For student learning.
Don’t we want ALL students to excel? What role are you playing in the lives of ALL the children in your classroom? School? District? Are you THE REASON for success?? Or for maintaining status quo? Or sadly, failure? Sometimes the hard questions are necessary to make change. No. Not sometimes. Always.
I’m going to send you to TWO stories. Ask yourself, who am I in this story based on what you currently do, your views, and your actions. Then decide if what you are currently doing represents what you really stand for in education.
A Tale of Two Labels
A Tale of Two Trees
In case you are still feeling like Gifted seems like elitism, let’s look with open eyes while we are being honest. There is so much that goes with gifted (isolation, mental exhaustion, intensities….) it’s pushing it to call it “gift”ed at all. Different. It means different. Just like every single child in your classroom. No one is the same. Gifted students deserve to learn every day like everyone else in the room.
Make the mind shift. I guarantee it will amaze you.